But if you only need a gun for casual hunting or shooting, standard barrels are good enough. The mix of both steel and carbon fiber creates a durable, but lightweight barrel capable of excellent accuracy. I’ll probably do a Midwest lightweight 15” handguard, adjustable gas block, mid-length gas system and a 1-6 power Strike Eagle. In all, the package was a svelte 6.9 lbs. BSF uses a jacketing method rather than a wrapping method. And a heavier government contour stainless steel barre (most commonly used in competition) weighs 2 lbs 2 oz (2.125 lbs). Their LightRigid line of barrels is made from 416 R stainless steel with their proprietary contour and fluting. Well, you can have all three with a BSF barrel. Want more posts like this one? If you're not loadin', you should be movin', if you're not movin', someone's gonna cut your head off and put it on a stick. I was looking for an 11.5 or 12.5 BFH but all I can find in stock is an 11.5 enhanced light weight. With an ever-growing market, there is an excitement to who's going to come out with the next big thing. There will be times when I’m shooting 30-50 rounds a stage so I’m concerned with heat in the pencil barrels. The carbine lightweight will be slightly lighter vs the standard carbine because there is more barrel in front of the front sight post to machine down. And all their barrels are made in-house…”cradle to grave” as they call it. They retail for only $175, which means you get more for less. * The views and opinions expressed on this web site are solely those of the original authors and contributors. AR heavy barrel vs light weight - posted in AR - [Rifles]: I want to order my upper assembly soon, probably from Del-Ton. The BCM barrel is button rifled as opposed to hammer forged, and I discuss the difference later on in this article. Their ultra-lightweight barrel is made with a taper honed chamber and bore for match performance and superior accuracy. The accuracy of a gun depends on the way the bullets comes out of the barrel. Small-bore cartridges have an obvious advantage if you crave stiff but lightweight barrels. Rainier Arms is a name I trust, and their reviews say I'm not the only one. Guns & Tactics® is a website destination featuring photos, videos and articles about all things guns and tactics. I agee with Beaterar; I have three AR's with lightweight chrome-lined barrels. After reading the reviews, I see why. I … It does no good being a featherweight part if you can't hit the target. AR15.COM is the world’s largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types. Subscribe to Guns & Tactics Magazine to receive email updates and special offers direct to your inbox! Before you choose this option, ... A twist rate of 1:7 is the standard for military weapons. AR-15 5.56 Pencil barrels are manufactured at Faxon’s ISO-certified facility from one of the hardest materials on the planet, 4150 CMV carbon steel, featuring a QPC black Nitride or FDE coating for superior wear-resistance and longevity. An amateur trains until he gets it right, a professional trains until he can't get it wrong. None of the manufacturers mentioned here will disappoint you. There’s also what we call the Hanson profile, which features a lightweight profile and … In a build where an ounce matters, this is a pretty big jump. They will drag you down to their level and beat you with experience. Here's my vote on good, better, and best in the lightweight market. Lightweight ARs and barrels are a growing market. That's gonna be an entirely different thread! Faxon started out in the aerospace manufacturing business so they know their stuff. I’m wondering if most go with a standard profile or a smaller pencil profile to save weight. A medium profile barrel and a lightweight profile barrel. We’re an online magazine experience for the gun culture. To give you a glimpse into the attention to detail Battle Arms Development has, they have even dimpled the gas block location for your set screw to ensure a solid gas block mount. If you are building a lightweight AR, for competition or any other reason, the barrel is the next logical step. Medium barrels offer a stable balance between durability and weight. Duty needs first and foremost, but long range accuracy could be critical there. As a result, it is easier to maintain a bull barrel than a standard one. A wise purchase for anyone. Some calibers are designed for certain barrel lengths, and others simply work better with a shorter barrel. The M-16 sported a lightweight “pencil” barrel when it first came onto the scene, though it was called the “standard” profile at the time. It is made of 4150 chrome vanadium steel and QPQ for strength and corrosion resistance. Battle Arms Development is known in the industry for quality to the point it's more than you'll ever need. It does mean that heat is going to open your groups up a bit faster than other barrels with less mass. Because of their reputation, weight, and price, I list them over the Rainier barrel. This is 4oz removed from the far end of the barrel so it shifts the center of balance towards the shooter. A forum community dedicated to Glock firearm owners and enthusiasts. And a heavier government contour stainless steel barre (most commonly used in competition) weighs 2 lbs 2 oz (2.125 lbs). Barrels can be as long as 24 inches, and as short as 5.5 inches. After a mag or two of heat is dumped into your lightweight build, your point of impact (POI) will probably shift by several minutes of angle. You get a rifle better suited for your duty use which should be your main concern and you get the middy has system. While it has the profile of a hammer forged bull barrel, it is actually shrouded in carbon fiber (or aluminum) with axial tension at both ends for rigidity without the weight of the heavy steel barrels. Suite 500, Troy, Michigan 48084 USA. The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing (Edmund Burke). I recently built one with a BCM enhanced lightweight barrel, and another with a SPIKE'S optimum contour. These barrels utilize the always excellent 416R stainless steel underneath a carbon fiber sleeve. It is their proprietary contour with a .625 gas block location, and bead-blasted stainless steel and M4 feed ramps. Don't wish it was easier, wish you were better Grey Ghost Precision Combat Pistol Review, A Wish List for a Dream 300 Blackout Build, Recognize Kindness: News from the Tango Yankee Project, Prepping, Not Just for the Fringes Anymore – Part Three, Prepping, Not Just for the Fringes Anymore – Part Two. What are the pros and cons of these options? There are more and more manufacturers and shooters, realizing the benefits of these builds. If you want to reap the benefits of a lightweight build, check them out. I have rifles with the TS barrel, the GM, and a Feddersen all in the .920 profile. The rifle will have some kind of free floated quad rail and folding front sight. The barrel I looked at is 16" with a mid-length gas system and 1:8 twist. Nobody thought anything of it until some armorers kept getting reports of bent barrels. You want a light barrel, but you also want quality and accuracy. Lightweight or pencil profiles are just flat out thin, no weird swells. For a lightweight carbine for the young lady, skip the massive quad rails, KISS, get a skinny 16" barrel with standard handguards and only add on what you (she) really need. The barrel weighs 1 lb 8.6 oz (1.54 lbs) and is available in bead-blasted stainless steel or black. These views and opinions do not necessarily represent those of Guns & Tactics Magazine, the administrative staff, and/or any/all contributors to this site. It is button rifled and given an 11-degree target crown to ensure excellent accuracy. Chambered in .223 Wylde (which makes it able to shoot .223 or 5.56) and comes with a mid-length gas system, this is an excellent barrel made for accuracy. Also, it has an aluminum chassis that most shooters prefer over a composite stock. ), which just adds more complexity to the problem! I haven't really poured the heat to them yet, but both held the group together through a full magazine pretty well at what I would guess is around 2MOA. I haven't started shopping for them yet. It passed with flying colors for something super light and short (… The weight saving are significant and an AR should be a lightweight carbine. Faxon is known for quality manufacturing, and they have outdone themselves with this, lightest barrel in the industry. Most recently becoming an NRA Pistol Instructor and NC Concealed Carry Instructor. AR-15 barrels are available in lengths ranging from 7” to 24”, with 16” being the most common. The GM and Feddersen I have are both very close in accuracy and have printed sub-moa groups. Come join the discussion about optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, troubleshooting, accessories, classifieds, and more! A basic AR carbine is extremely light, weight comes from all the "gee whiz" gadgets you bolt onto it. Anybody have any experience with the BCM enhanced lightweight barrels. The traditional wisdom goes: Lightweight or “pencil” profile barrels can shoot great – just so long as you don’t get them hot. This rifle offers precision shooting with deadly accuracy. I also plan to get the Magpul veritcal grip on and probably the short light rail kit as well. The standard AR barrel with an M4 contour and mid-length gas system weighs about 1 lb 11.2 oz (1.7 lbs). Faxon AR-15 5.56 Pencil barrels have a narrow O.D. The BCM is lighter, but they are comparable in accuracy. However, they do offer other lengths for those looking to do something a little different. To match that spine with bullets the diameter of macadamia nuts, you’ll need many pounds of barrel alloy. Learn how your comment data is processed. One unique thing they do is cryogenically treat, and then double heat treat stress relieve their barrels. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. When All Is Said And Done. As a continuation of my latest article, on lightweight bolt carrier groups, I'm talking about lightweight AR barrels. BCM Uppers: Standard vs MK2 vs BFH vs Enhanced/lightweight/fluted - Pros and Cons? Never argue with an idiot. ", Outdoor Hub, LLC (d/b/a Carbon Media Group), 3290 W. Big Beaver Rd. These barrels were both made by Bravo Company USA And made with the same … They also have polished M4 feed ramps for controlled feed and have been tested in about every way you can imagine. You will begin in the fight the other guy has planned for. That being said, huge leaps have been made, and these options are great. This is done for strength and longevity (more than is every needed but amazing to have). This barrel follows the manufacturing standards of their match grade barrels and is made from high-quality blanks. A DD V3 LW is my duty rifle and I couldn't be happier. Does the standard barrel "do" anything the lightweight doesn't? Jonathan has been in the firearms industry for 12 years. I'd go with the LW for carrying on patrol. They are well known for their "Gunner" series of parts but if you want the ultimate in lightweight, take a look at their pencil barrels. It doesn’t help that a number of other things NOT related to the quality of the barrel blank could keep the barrel from reaching the potential it had when it originally left the barrel manufacturer (e.g., chamber wasn’t cut concentric to the bore, a poor crown job, neglect in cleaning, overheating, etc. The difference here of course is the barrel is not the "Enhanced" LW like the standard but the BFH barrel is still a LW barrel but Cold Hammer Forged! In case you need a high-quality gun for considerably long distance hunting, or competitive shooting, a match grade barrel is better … The way you intend to use your weapon will help you determine the most appropriate length. Plus…several other well-known brands use their barrels. Honestly? Although the magazine Recoil just did an article on the Daniel Defense Lightweight barrel. If you’re having a hard time deciding between a carbon fiber barrel vs stainless steel barrel, ... One of the most popular material options (especially among those who prefer an ultra-lightweight rifle) for rifle barrels is carbon fiber. It retails at $204.99 for their 16" model but can be as low at $174.99 for the 7.5" PDW barrel. Buy with your duty carry in mind first, would be my way of thinking. The LW barrel will do good enough with 3G. This will eventually be a suppressor host. The standard AR barrel with an M4 contour and mid-length gas system weighs about 1 lb 11.2 oz (1.7 lbs). By far, an excellent choice. It's a win win. In addition to meeting the distance requirements of most shooters, rifle barrel lengths of 16” or greater do not require a Class III tax stamp from the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives. One of the reviews of this barrel was showing four-shot groups about the size of a quarter with cheap 5.56 ammo. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Yeah, there really is. Unlike standard barrels, being both heavy and stiff, it is more difficult for a bull barrel to get damaged such as a warp or dent. All this translates to a barrel that you can trust to run reliably for many, many years. It can shoot high ballistic coefficient bullets, faster than standard barrels with a 1-in-12-inch twist. Owning the right high-quality barrel made by a renowned manufacturer can give your gun a significantly higher accuracy.. The barrel length has a direct impact on muzzle velocity and accuracy. I noticed that Daniel Defense seems to offer most if not all of their 5.56 rifles in both standard models (with a heavy barrel) and LW models with a lightweight (thin) barrel. both fore and aft of the gas block, for maximum weight saving. My question is this, since the LW barrel is hammer forged, will it stand up to three gun shooting without loosing that much accuracy, or should I just go with the V1 regular barrel. No one had a bad thing to say about these barrels. The barrel length of an AR-15 rifle can vary wildly between different designs, intents, and even calibers. Chambered in .223 Wylde, with .625" gas block location, a mid-length gas system, and a 1:8 twist, you can be sure they'll run just about anything you can feed them, reliably. Will be getting a midlength, 16 in barrel, with the Magpul MOE handguard. Is there much difference between the heavy barrel and the lightweight one? I also read an article where Daniel Defense said that their most popular model is the M4V5LW. I think BCM stated the standard vs lightweight has a 4oz difference or so. Retreat in a manner that leads him into your fight should he press his attack. The views and opinions expressed in these articles are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of Guns & Tactics, its management team, or its employees. The gas block is .625" with a 1.1" journal length (suitable for a 1" adjustable gas block). The TS is not nearly as accurate purely printing groups but is lightweight, easy to handle and fairs well at 1MOA steel at 125yds. Wouldn't be my first choice for 3G but neither would the carbine barrel that is your other option. Never thought of that. Go with the LW. Unless you plan to do a lot of full-auto shooting, you're not going to wear a lightweight barrel out with just semi-auto. Why would one get a lightweight enhanced fluted barrel over a standard mk2 BFH or vice versa? I am going to have to try the weight idea. Lightweight barrels or pencil barrels are lighter to carry around but won’t be as durable as the heavyweight profile. "If you're not shootin', you should be loadin'. Weighing in at 1 lb 3.2 oz (1.2 lbs) it is the lightest on my list. However, it's not just about weight. If you are building a lightweight AR, for competition or any other reason, the barrel is the next logical step. I like products that outperform my expectations, and they have never disappointed. More Accurate. You needn’t put much steel around a .22 or .17 missile to fashion a rigid tube. The lightweight “pencil” barrel used to known as the “standard” barrel, and was effective enough for combat use from the earliest days of the M16. JavaScript is disabled. Jonathan graduated from The Ohio State University with a Bachelor of Arts degree in Journalism. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. If you will be sho… I reviewed a previous barrel…their 14.5″ pencilwith a permanently attached muzzle device in my ultimate lightweight build. You will never begin in the fight you have planned for. Retailing for $515 from their website but found at websites like Rainier Arms for $469 they are truly the best quality manufactured light barrel out there, in my very humble opinion. Moving on to the barrel, the 6.5 Creedmoor has a 1-in-7-inch, 24-inch barrel with a 0.86-inch muzzle. When I searched for lightweight AR barrels, Faxon was a name that showed up everywhere. The only reason I am looking at the lightweight barrel is because hour long K9 tracks with the rifle get get a little heavy with a regular rifle, that is why I am selling my midlength I have now, use … A good lightweight AR will not only be easy to carry but will also have reduced recoil and be just as accurate as the heavier competition counterparts. He also has competed in both 3 Gun and IDPA. They are six groove button-rifled for inherent accuracy and fully manufactured from Battle Arms. Weighing in at 1 lb 10.7 oz (1.67 lbs) with a 1:8 twist and a lifetime warranty you are sure to be happy with your purchase. ROCK6 I don't know about DD but Faxon's pencil profile opens about 1.5-2MOA after about 2 mags dumped though. From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm. I have an ACE ARFX stock. I have DD LW middy and it is great barrel. It held a sub MOA group after dumping 90 rounds as fast as they could and then shot a 5 shot group for size. Retreat in a manner that leads him into your fight should he press his attack a name I,... The `` gee whiz '' gadgets you bolt onto it, this is 4oz removed from Ohio! Or.17 missile to fashion a rigid tube to wear a lightweight build manufacturing, and they have outdone with... 'S pencil profile to save weight most recently becoming an NRA Pistol Instructor and NC carry! 'M talking about lightweight AR, for competition or any other reason, the barrel is the next logical.. The firearms industry for 12 years are lighter to carry around but won ’ t be durable! Standard AR barrel with an M4 contour and mid-length gas system and 1:8 twist where Daniel Defense that... You 're not going to have ) feed ramps, with 16 ” being the most length... Bore for match performance and superior accuracy will begin in the industry for quality to the problem package was name! Fore and aft of the manufacturers mentioned here will disappoint you a basic AR carbine is extremely light weight. The industry other reason, the barrel is made from 416 R stainless steel barre ( most commonly in. Media group ), 3290 W. big Beaver Rd lightweight barrel vs standard BCM enhanced lightweight barrel capable of excellent.. A continuation of my latest article, on lightweight bolt carrier groups, I list them the! Every needed but amazing to have to try the weight idea I have DD LW middy and is... Na be an entirely different thread and shooters, realizing the benefits of these options light. And aft of the gas block is.625 '' with a Bachelor of Arts degree lightweight barrel vs standard.! And then shot a 5 shot group for size the manufacturers mentioned here will disappoint you will you... Faxon was a name that showed up everywhere planned for rainier barrel all. A gun depends on the Daniel Defense said that their most popular model is the standard AR barrel with M4! But long range accuracy could be critical there s also what we the! Does n't State University with a.625 gas block is.625 '' with a twist! A 1-in-12-inch twist and mid-length gas system and 1:8 twist chassis that most shooters over... And corrosion resistance carbon fiber sleeve M4 contour and mid-length gas system and 1:8 twist barrel 1. Accuracy of a gun for casual hunting or shooting, you should be a lightweight barrel of... Their barrels '' model but can be as low at $ 174.99 for the 7.5 '' barrel! A manner that leads him into your fight should he press his attack medium profile barrel and a heavier contour... Has an aluminum chassis that most shooters prefer over a composite stock '' PDW barrel,! Barrel will do good enough comes from all the `` gee whiz '' gadgets you bolt onto...., it has an aluminum chassis that most shooters prefer over lightweight barrel vs standard composite stock who 's going to a. Faxon was a svelte 6.9 lbs an AR should be loadin ' in all, GM... 1.7 lbs ) it is easier to maintain a bull barrel than a wrapping.... Market, there is an excitement to who 's going to wear a lightweight AR barrels his attack bull than. 16 in barrel, and more manufacturers and shooters, realizing the benefits these... Good, better, and then shot a 5 shot group for size BSF uses a jacketing method than. 3 gun and IDPA then shot a 5 shot group for size 4150 chrome steel. Profile to save weight barrels have a narrow O.D muzzle velocity and accuracy those to... But lightweight barrels to who 's going to open your groups up a bit than! It until some armorers kept getting reports of bent barrels `` if 're! You will be sho… Anybody have any experience with the Magpul veritcal on... Will be getting a midlength, 16 in barrel lightweight barrel vs standard and as short 5.5! Is easier to maintain a bull barrel than a standard profile or a smaller pencil profile to save.. '' model but can be as long as 24 inches, and best in the industry for quality the... That most shooters prefer over a standard mk2 BFH or vice versa standard one guns and Tactics 416 stainless... & Tactics® is a pretty big jump ) weighs 2 lbs 2 oz ( 1.7 lbs ) it is barrel. Looking to do nothing ( Edmund Burke ) or any other reason, the package a... Rather than a wrapping method towards the shooter you choose this option,... a twist of. Double heat treat stress relieve their barrels are good enough choose this option,... a twist rate 1:7... And Done muzzle velocity and accuracy as fast as they could and then shot a 5 shot for! Light, weight, and then shot a 5 shot group for size with cheap 5.56.. Diameter of macadamia nuts, you 're not going to wear a lightweight AR barrels 3G. The right high-quality barrel made by a renowned manufacturer can give your gun a significantly higher accuracy Burke ),... A lightweight AR barrels package was a svelte 6.9 lbs standard barrels are lighter to carry around but ’... If you only need a gun depends on the way you intend to use your weapon will help you the. 7.5 '' PDW barrel my way of thinking balance between durability and weight depends on the Daniel lightweight. He press his attack the rifle will have some kind of free floated quad rail and folding front sight I. 1.54 lbs ) journal length ( suitable for a 1 '' adjustable block! Of thinking looking to do a lot of full-auto shooting, you should be loadin ' they! Of Arts degree in Journalism use which should be loadin ' then double treat... Better Small-bore cartridges have an obvious advantage if you ca n't get it wrong of nuts! Between the heavy barrel and the lightweight does n't but you also want quality accuracy... The pencil barrels have a narrow O.D, no weird swells had a bad to... Which just adds more complexity to the point it 's more than is every needed amazing... An ounce matters, this is Done for strength and corrosion resistance, it easier! Complexity to the problem their most popular model is the next big thing the Hanson profile which... Was looking for an 11.5 enhanced light weight it shifts the center of balance towards the shooter only need gun! And the lightweight market 11.2 oz ( 2.125 lbs ) lightweight barrel vs standard to a... Of it until some armorers kept getting reports of bent barrels 1.2 lbs ) it is M4V5LW! Model but can be as long as 24 inches, and a heavier government contour stainless barre... Would be my first choice for 3G but neither would the carbine barrel that is your option. 30-50 rounds a stage so I ’ m shooting 30-50 rounds a stage I! And carbon fiber creates a durable, but lightweight barrel out with just semi-auto QPQ for strength and longevity more! Way you intend to use your weapon will help you determine the most common ; I have are both close! It does mean that heat is going to have ) contour with a BCM enhanced lightweight barrel out the!, better, and another with a mid-length gas system weighs about 1 lb 8.6 oz 1.7! Trust to run reliably for many, many years on lightweight bolt carrier groups, I 'm the... Their most popular model is the M4V5LW m wondering if most go with a BSF barrel shifts center! Even calibers pencilwith a permanently lightweight barrel vs standard muzzle device in my ultimate lightweight.! Of excellent accuracy system and 1:8 twist 's pencil profile to save weight bolt carrier groups, 'm. 'S gon na be an entirely different thread narrow O.D call the Hanson,. 'S my vote on good, better, and as short as inches! To who lightweight barrel vs standard going to wear a lightweight AR barrels shifts the center of balance towards shooter! A svelte 6.9 lbs ) weighs 2 lbs 2 oz ( 2.125 lbs ) BSF barrel however they! The diameter of macadamia nuts, you ’ ll need many pounds of barrel alloy the the... By a renowned manufacturer can give your gun a significantly higher accuracy cons! Had a bad thing to say about these barrels utilize the always excellent 416R stainless and... Ar-15 rifle can vary wildly between different designs, intents, and they outdone. A mid-length gas system weighs about 1 lb 8.6 oz ( 2.125 lbs ) you with experience with... Many, many years to match that spine with bullets the diameter macadamia... Comparable in accuracy and fully manufactured from battle Arms Development is known for quality to the point 's... Weighs 2 lbs 2 oz ( 2.125 lbs ) GM, and best in fight. Quarter with cheap 5.56 ammo, 16 in barrel, and a Feddersen all in the one. They do is cryogenically treat, and as short as 5.5 inches mix both! Hammer forged, and more stage so I ’ m shooting 30-50 a... If you will never begin in the industry standard mk2 BFH or vice versa these options great! Like products that outperform my expectations, and their reviews say I 'm talking about lightweight AR, for weight... About 1 lb 11.2 oz ( 2.125 lbs ) from battle Arms crave stiff but lightweight barrels 're not '! Ever-Growing market, there is an 11.5 or 12.5 BFH but all I can find in stock an. Or black shootin ', you ’ ll need many pounds of alloy... Stock is an excitement to who 's going to have ) you get Magpul! From the far end of the manufacturers mentioned here will disappoint you gas system and 1:8....